Is social media realtime or permanent?

26 comments
Editing: Is social media realtime or permanent?:


As social media has (somewhat) matured, an interesting culture has grown up around the idea of editing social media content. And for reasons that I don't understand, it isn't one culture--it seems as though every kind of social media has developed its own culture around editing content. It is as if we can't decide whether social media is a realtime force that is stream of consciousness and should never be changed, or it is a permanent record of activity that ought to be updated as it changes, or something in between. Some kinds of social media (Wikipedia) couldn't exist without editing while others (Twitter) do not even allow editing. What gives?

To me, it shows both that we use different kinds of social media for different purposes (think Wikipedia vs. Twitter) but it also shows an ambivalence over what we expect social media to be. So, while it is perfectly reasonable for most people to say that Wikipedia is all about the editing--what we want to see is the latest groupthink on a subject--Wikipedia also contains and exhaustive revision history for every page for transparency into how the page has evolved over time.

But most social media venues fall far short of that kind of transparency. As the founder of the Biznology blog, I struggle with exactly how to handle edits. Very frequently, I see typos, broken links, or other problems crop up on blog pages--sometimes freshly-minted posts and sometimes posts from years ago--and I usually just change them without documenting the changes. One exception is when a commenter points out an error--then I thank the commenter and note that the change has been applied.

Now, if there is a substantive error--a fact is wrong or a breaking story needs to be updated--I change the post and clearly mark that it was updated, along with the date it was changed. This has evolved as the way to edit posts in the blogging world. But I struggle as to when to do that. I have many posts that give advice that is now outdated, because it was good advice in 2006 but not terribly relevant now. Those posts are still out there and they come up in search results. Often, much of the post is still good advice, so I am not sure I should remove the posts, but some of the advice is not helpful. Should I go back and edit those? There is no clear blogging editing norm for outdated posts.

How about YouTube? Mostly videos don't get edited. They just sit out there forever and you can upload a new video if you want to cover the same subject again. Does that make sense? I don't know.

But social networks are my favorite. Facebook and Twitter allow no editing at all. So, you can post something that gets retweeted a hundred times and notice there is a huge, dumb typo in it and you can't change it. You are forced to leave it out there or to delete the tweet. How many stories have you read about someone tweeting something embarrassing where the offending tweet has been deleted by the time the story runs, leaving you with the obligatory screen shot of the rogue tweet to prove that it really happened, because Twitter now has no record of the exchange. There is something wrong when the most newsworthy things that happen are lost to history. Bloggers can take down their own content also, so it's not just Twitter and Facebook, but bloggers could edit a post to add an apology and they can answer comments with new comments.

Google+, ostensibly the same type of social media as Twitter and Facebook, does allow editing. While Google+ has not caught on yet, I think that Google will stick with it until it finds a following, so it will be interesting to see if people take advantage of being able to edit an embarrassing Google+ post, and how transparent they will be as they do it. Does Google show everyone that you edited your post? Or, like blogging, is it up to you how transparent you are?

Message boards are equally schizophrenic. Some do not allow any editing of posts. Some allow editing whenever you want. Some allow editing, but only within a short window and then the post becomes permanent. As with blogging, it's up to you as to how transparent you are about your changes.

One of the reasons editing is so important is that social media often starts a conversation. If I write something and ten people start talking about it, then is it reasonable for me to edit my original post even if it makes the conversation that already exists look weird? Wikipedia hosts a discussion about improving the page which obviously becomes outdated as those improvements are adopted, but at least you can look at the version of the page that people were talking about if you want to.

26 comments :

  1. Great article and I enjoyed reading it. It was well written and it has also a great content. Big thanks for sharing.


    web design Philippines

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hii..:-)
    Good Post shared here based Social media..i was looking for this information..thanks for sharing this post..i did get lots of good information from here. keep posting such post here in future too. it would be nice if you can share some information related to url directory submission here in your future posts..

    Thanks,

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hello,

    Good post..:-)
    Thanks for sharing and keep posting such post here in future too.
    url directory submission

    Thanks,

    ReplyDelete
  4. Social media is where millions of people spend most of their time, and that's why it has a big effect when you use this strategy on seo.


    Cris | Link Building Services Philippines

    ReplyDelete
  5. nice post .. thanks for sharing look forward to more post
    california seo company

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hey... Nice post..Social media is very effective technique in seo to get more traffic towards the website.

    Social Media Optimization

    ReplyDelete
  7. Thanks for posting this. Very nice recap of some of the key points in my talk. I hope you and your readers find it useful! Thanks again Mcx tips free trial

    ReplyDelete
  8. Pretty cool place you’ve came. Thanx for it. I favour such themes and everything connected to them. I might wish to browse a trifle a lot of thereon journal before long.
    Seo Company In Nasik

    ReplyDelete
  9. Very nice article. I would like to share some useful auto approved blog list for beginners.

    http://seo-tipsforyou.blogspot.in/
    http://searchengineoptimizationexpertsindia.blogspot.in/
    http://websitedesignseouk.blogspot.in/
    http://trafficwebsitetips.blogspot.in/
    http://getwebsitetraffictips.blogspot.in/
    http://iphoneappnewsinside.blogspot.in/
    http://healthyrecipeslife.blogspot.in/
    http://onlineshoppingtipsuk.blogspot.in/
    http://healthtipsforhealthylife.blogspot.in/
    http://sinf-vivek.blogspot.in/

    ReplyDelete
  10. Each option has its own pros and cons, but I would rather have blogs and social networking sites unedited. When you enable editing, you risk losing credibility since you can just withdraw your words whenever you like it. That's what happened with Wikipedia. Some people think of it as an unreliable source. People might also be confused with the information you are feeding them.

    Darryl Tay

    ReplyDelete
  11. Social media is very important to advertising purpose,because most of members will very crazy about the social media like facebook,twitter etc. Seo Company Bangalore

    ReplyDelete
  12. Social media is where millions of people spend most of their time, and that's why it has a big effect when you use this strategy on seo.i suggest my friends to join your blog. now i will go to niagara with niagara falls tours and tell new updates of your site,

    ReplyDelete
  13. I always suggest my friends to read your seo blog. Social media is where millions of people spend most of their time, and that's why it has a big effect when you use this strategy on seo. now i will agin recommend my friends when i went to niagara with niagara falls tours

    ReplyDelete
  14. Really your post is really very good and its effective..
    Limestone Fireplaces Wakefield

    ReplyDelete
  15. God post. Social media optimization is the best way to increase website traffic


    ------------
    Smo Services

    ReplyDelete
  16. Utilizing the live forex outlines for a specialized investigation frames the establishment of forex exchanging signals. In any case, there is never be a 100% certification utilizing these forex exchanging signals and there are a few components to think about when you're picking one.To kmow more take a tour Hot Forex Signals

    ReplyDelete
  17. I like this post it matters a lot for online marketers and business owners.Thank you Business Directory Listing India, Local Business Listing

    ReplyDelete
  18. You made some decent factors there. I looked on the internet for the difficulty and found most individuals will associate with along with your website.Keep update more excellent posts.

    Digital marketing company in Chennai

    ReplyDelete
  19. Thank you for having taken your time to provide us with your valuable information relating to your stay with us.we are sincerely concerned.., Most importantly, you Keepit the major...
    seo company in chennai

    ReplyDelete
  20. Thank you for taking the time to provide us with your valuable information. We strive to provide our candidates with excellent care.As always, we appreciate you confidence and trust in us.

    SEO Company in Chennai
    SEO Services in Chennai

    ReplyDelete
  21. Thank you for sharing such a nice and interesting blog with us. Hope it might be much useful for us. keep on updating...!!
    seo company in india
    digital marketing company in india

    ReplyDelete
  22. Superb. I really enjoyed very much with this article here. Really it is an amazing article I had ever read. I hope it will help a lot for all. Thank you so much for this amazing posts and please keep update like this excellent article.thank you for sharing such a great blog with us. expecting for your.
    Digital Marketing Company in India

    ReplyDelete
  23. Thank you for the fresh content and information you provide. This really helps learner like me. Keep sharing knowledge. Happy to read.

    Hadoop Training in Chennai

    ReplyDelete

Blogger news

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

Labels

seo tips seo beginners seo techniques seo starter guide seo beginners tips PPC Tips ppc advertising tips seo updates seo beginners guide seo helps Dharmesh Talaviya SEO Executive adwords tips google algorithm google update ppc campaign tips ppc search engine tips ppc tricks seo guidelines 5 seo tips SEO Executive black hat seo collaboration microhoo google news joomla seo joomla seo tips joomla seo tools joomla seo tutorial linkwheel sites on page seo tips search engine marketing search engine optimisation search engine updates seo advise seo loophole seo news seo tips for beginners seo tools seo update tppc tips yahoo and bing collaboration "panda" update 17th jan 301 redirect Dharmesh Google Microsoft Buys 8 SEO Domain Names Online PPC Advertising tips Penalty Recover Talaviya adwords tools articles go viral automatically shares links basic principles of seo best blog sites best web 2.0 sites best web 2.0 sites for linkwheel best web 2.0 sites for seo bing bing search engine algorithm bing updates blog helps blog tips blogger tips blogs tricks bookmarking sites canonical tag canonical url content easily linkable cornucopia of updates dofollow social bookmarking site list drupal seo tips dynamic link building facebook preferences fastest growing search engine free banner ads free blog site list free social bookmarking site list freelance link building freelancing seo getting inbound links google algorithm news google algorithm update google algorithm update 2010 google algorithm update analysis google blog search google instant google instant messenger google instant search google jan 2013 update google latest news google search engine algorithm google search results update google search tips google search tricks google seo helps google seo search google seo search tricks google seo tools google seo update google update 2010 google's farmer update google's popular search tool google’s market share growing search engine in america high pr social bookmarking site list high pr social bookmarking sites how to improve search engine results increase rss subscribers instant messaging keyword analysis keyword discovery keyword popularity research keyword ranking keyword research keyword research articles keyword search landing page seo link bait content link bait post type linkwheel linkwheel site list linkwheel sites list list of blog sites list of social bookmarking sites making link building meta tag tips microblogiing microsoft update most popular organic seo columns networking events no follow code on page seo factors on page seo techniques online ppc courses tips page load time pay per click advertising popular organic seo columns ppc online info ppc software ppc tools ppc tools google quality backlink rganic seo columns robot .txt file robots.txt tutorial search engine algorithm search engine in the us search engine marketing strategies search engine news search engine optimization techniques search results ranking algorithm seo seo advice seo algorithm seo algorithm 2010 seo algorithm update seo beginners guidelines seo checklist seo columns seo daily update seo factors seo first step guide seo freelancer seo games seo guide seo helper seo microblogging seo news 2013 seo news jan 2013 seo people seo practitioners writing seo quiz seo search results seo search terms seo standpoint seo strategy seo tactics seo target keywords seo tasks seo tchnique seo update 2010 seomoz social media works social network websites social networking site social segments for tracking software giant study traditional marketing target keywords the difference between a like and a link twitter preferences upgrade to bing search engine url shorteners use search engines web 2.0 web 2.0 site list web 2.0 sites web 2.0 sites list word tracker yahoo news yahoo product lines yahoo to use bing search engine yahoo updates
.